Sunday, June 05, 2005

Does democracy work?

I was always against reservation policy of Indian govn. . I am sure all the great minds behind its inception never wanted it to be this way. The way it is being implemented right now doesn’t come close to serving its purpose – “To provide equal opportunity to all across the society”. If you observe carefully you can see that this has done nothing but raise the gulf between the rich and poor of the scheduled castes and tribes. I agree it was started with a noble intention but if something hasn’t worked for 50 years don’t you think time has come to try something else. How can people be so blind? This has infact lead to India’s society being divided into two categories – reserved and unreserved.

But the most ridiculous thing is reservation in the house of representatives – the Lok sabha and Rajya sabha. I expected that in modern India, it’s youth will rise against such policies. But to my surprise a large group in India who almost form 50% of the population (read women) are asking for their reservation in the houses. Infact they project themselves being very fair as they are asking only for 33% of the seats. Bullshit. Any demand for reservation in the representative houses is based on three assumptions –

One, only members of one group can help others in that group. Two, Parliament must function like a pollster's sample group and constitute an exact reflection of the composition of society. And three, people don't vote as they should. Combination of these three assumptions cries out loudly - DEMOCRACY SIMPLY DOESN’T WORK.

So those fighting for this noble cause should first decide what they are fighting for. If such a large population fights for a just cause like removing reservation from all aspects of Indian society then I guess India will be a much better democracy as well as country. This is what I feel!!

3 comments:

vishnoi said...

democracy works.. but indian politics aint the best place to see it :(
hopefully the new generation of politicians shall change the way congress/bjp and what not have shaped the country.

Roman said...

Panda...Its nice to read something like this...keep posting such stuff
Neway...coming to this...I never really thought abt reservations too much until my sister lost her medical seat on one of the entrances due to them. I am not a supporter of reservation...like u said...they are being misused by
a) undeserving candidates who dont really have a disadvantage to begin with!
b) politicians who want to be in power to make some money thru corruption
Nothing new said here...just giving my op...but I have a question
"And three, people don't vote as they should"
Cud u explain what u mean?

Panda said...

Ro: basically democracy runs on this fact that people will elect the candidate who they feel is the best. Whoes manifesto they like.. And not who is from their cast and all..so one major defense of reservation is there is not enough representation from all casts..but the ideal way shld be to allow everybody to stand in election (which according to me is equality of opportnity)and then let the people decide who to elect.